About Supreme Bakery
Supreme Bakery is a beloved West Orange destination where tradition, craftsmanship, and everyday convenience come together in one warm and welcoming place. Located at 40 Main St, West Orange, NJ 07052, this landmark bakeshop has earned its reputation by serving fresh, satisfying favorites from morning to night. Whether you are starting your day with a coffee and breakfast pastry, picking up a box of donuts for the office, or ordering a custom cake for a special celebration, Supreme Bakery offers the kind of quality and variety that keeps customers coming back. Their menu of custom cakes, bagels, donuts, and other sweet treats reflects the care and attention that make a bakery and cake shop such a vital part of the community—turning ordinary moments into memorable ones and giving customers a dependable place for both everyday treats and once-in-a-lifetime occasions. What makes Supreme Bakery especially appealing is how easy it is to enjoy their offerings in the way that works best for you. With delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, on-site services, and takeaway available, customers can choose the option that fits their schedule and preferences. The shop is designed for quick visits, making it a convenient stop for busy mornings or last-minute needs, and the wheelchair-accessible entrance helps ensure a welcoming experience for more guests. Supreme Bakery also serves coffee and is especially known for breakfast, making it a dependable choice for those who want a fresh and flavorful start to the day. Customers have responded with strong enthusiasm, giving the bakery a 4.40 out of 5 rating based on 805 reviews, a clear sign of the trust and satisfaction it has built over time. With credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments accepted, getting your favorite baked goods is simple and seamless. For orders or questions, call +1 973-736-1732 and experience a bakery that combines convenience, quality, and the comfort of a neighborhood favorite.
Business Hours
Customer Reviews
They did a cake and cupcakes for my son’s birthday and it was exactly what I wanted. I booked with them based off the reviews and was left a very happy and satisfied customer. Customer service is very efficient and reliable. I never had an issue getting in touch with any of the staff over the phone. The environment of …
I have been a long time customer of Supreme bakery. They have provided specialty themed sheet cakes for 3 Grandsons, 1 Greatgranddaughter, Daughter, Siblings and other family members for all of our special occasions. If there has ever been any issues or mishaps, the owner has ALWAYS redeemed himself. As we all know, stuff happens. Perfection doesn't exist. Nowadays the …
Supreme Bakery is hands down one of the best spots in West Orange. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel like family. The food? Absolutely top tier. Everything is fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. You can taste the quality in every bite. Whether you’re stopping in for something …
My family really enjoyed the birthday cake. It has been a very long time since my family had supreme bakery desserts. So to get together and taste memories again was greatly satisfying. The buttercream still tastes the same -my family really enjoyed. Thank you
Everything was absolutely delicious! The pastry fruit tarts were phenomenal! The cake was amazing and super moist! Thanks! My mom loved it!
Supreme Bakery is our community bakery with a wide variety of sweet treats. I have been shopping with them over 10 years, and I have never had any major issues. I had only 1 issue which was rectified immediately, and professionally. However, Shopping over 10 years with only 1 issue, is considered excellent because no where you go is ever …
I tried the tiramisu and the coconut cupcakes, and both were absolutely delicious! The tiramisu was beautifully presented, with an edible design on top that made it extra special — creamy, rich, and full of flavor. The coconut cupcakes were so well done, topped with a bright cherry that made them look as good as they tasted. My grandma especially …
Bought a pineapple filled birthday cake for my girlfriend. She loved the look and especially the taste of the cake. Had to order it the day prior, and it was ready exactly when they said it would be. Staff is/was attentive and friendly. Place is clean, and the array was mouth watering to look at. Five stars.
Great experience overall. Cakes are pretty good here and the baker did a good job with the design. The only thing was that a bit of the blue from the gender reveal got on the outside of the cake and was visible before cutting the cake—which of course was a little disappointing, so I would just recommend examining more in …
Let say first, the cake was so beautiful and tasty, that everyone was impressed. The birthday girl really was surprised. Stacey did an awesome job, helping placing this order. She gave me advice on everything to go with the cake I wanted. For those who wanted to know, I ordered a red velvet cake with buttercream frosting and filling. The …
