About Suprema
Suprema is a rustic-chic Italian café and gourmet market in Rutherford, New Jersey, offering a welcoming setting for organic Italian sandwiches, freshly prepared pastas, and packaged goods. Whether you are stopping in for a quick bite, planning a relaxed meal, or looking for prepared foods and specialty items to enjoy later, Suprema brings together the comfort of an Italian restaurant with the convenience of a gourmet market. Its menu includes coffee, comfort food, healthy options, organic dishes, small plates, desserts, and meals suited to brunch, lunch, and dinner. Guests can choose from outdoor seating, dine-in service, takeaway, kerbside pickup, delivery, and on-site services. Suprema is also known for fast service and great coffee, making it a practical choice for a casual meal, solo dining, or a quiet coffee break, while its private dining room and catering offerings provide options for a range of dining plans. The atmosphere is casual, cozy, quiet, and trendy, with table service available and reservations accepted. Free Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi access, a restroom, and gender-neutral toilets add further convenience during your visit. Suprema is committed to accessible dining, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance, wheelchair-accessible seating, and a wheelchair-accessible toilet. Customers rate the restaurant 4.60 out of 5 based on 528 reviews, reflecting its appeal as a destination for Italian sandwiches, pastas, coffee, prepared foods, and local specialties. Credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments are accepted. Visit Suprema at 92 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, United States, or call +1 201-531-1190.
Business Hours
Customer Reviews
This place is absolutely gorgeous! Very clean and the food was delicious. I do not remember the name of the plates, but for those who love a visual here you go! My kids had the spaghetti and meat ball and of course I had to take a bite! Lol Oh one thing I can remember the muscles 😍 if you …
One of my favorite places to stop & eat! Whether it’s for a quick bite to get some work done at the bar or a nice relaxing sit down lunch with some friends!! Favorite lunch specials is the chicken, mozzarella sandwich on a fabulous crunchy bread. Also is the pasta with chunks of mozzarella seen here !! Their desserts are …
Just left a wonderful lunch at Suprema. Our server was fantastic, and we enjoyed everything we ate - most importantly they let us linger and have a really leisurely experience. Artichoke salad is 10/10 and service and vibe is even better.
Hello my Foodies! So I was at this place for my friends Birthday. They have real food meaning made fresh and organic. I could tell it tasted so Different from the processed food I am used to I guess. Everything tasted fresh, and it did take me a minute to get into this food, but after a bit, I really …
Myself and my husband are Rutherford locals and this has been our favorite restaurant since we moved. It was our first lunch spot when we closed on our house and this past Sunday we hosted our baby shower at Suprema. I can’t say enough about how wonderful the experience was. The owners are wonderful, accommodating and responsive working with us …
My husband and I had a very enjoyable evening at Suprema, the food was delicious and our server Ricardo was attentive, caring, and very helpful. He made the experience even more enjoyable. We look forward to coming back!
I’ve visited Suprema multiple times and the quality is always consistent and delicious. Just had an amazing lunch with rice balls, meatballs, and two sandwiches: the roast beef and the chicken parm with vodka sauce. The bread had the perfect softness and crunch, and everything tasted as phenomenal as it looked. I’ve tried their pasta before too and it’s always …
Loved this place! BYOB with a liquor store right across the street and they gave us an ice bucket for our drinks. The vibes and music were on point that’s the first thing I noticed. Great service, friendly staff, and the food was good. Would definitely recommend this place.
Suprema was always good, however they have more recently elevated their food to a 5 star level. Lunch for 2 consisted of 2 of the specials: gnocchi suprema and spicy monique sandwich. Both were outstanding! And our darling waitress had the kitchen spilt the order! Very delicious! ( and I love that the specials are offered for lunch and dinner).
I had my baby shower here and it was a dream!!! The food is truly unbelievably good and the staff went so above and beyond to make sure we had a great experience. I could rave about this place for hours and hours. Chicken parm is unreal, artichoke salad is incredible, the meatballs are amazing, their vodka sauce is delicious, …
