About Simple Simon Bakery

Discover Simple Simon Bakery, a standout Restaurants in Appleton, WI, known for fresh flavors, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. With a 4.60-star rating from 607 reviews, our team is proud to offer great service and quality and accessible facilities for every guest.

Last updated: Jun 03, 2026

Business Hours

Closed · Saturday 5 AM-2 PM
Wednesday 3 AM-5:30 PM
Thursday 3 AM-5:30 PM
Friday 3 AM-5:30 PM
Saturday 5 AM-2 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 3 AM-5:30 PM
Tuesday 3 AM-5:30 PM

Customer Reviews

4.60
Based on 607 reviews
J
Josh and Alyssa

We recommend using Simple Simon Bakery for any of your bakery needs. Dawn made the cupcakes and cakes for our wedding. She was very easy to work with and responsive to emails. The whole process of working with Simple Simon Bakery is convenient. We had a taste testing and after that initial tasting we bought a few more samples to …

L
LauraLee Clement

My first visit to this place left me pleasantly surprised, and now I’m asking myself why I’ve never stopped in before! The atmosphere is incredibly quaint and has that warm, hometown charm that makes you feel instantly welcome. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, take your time, and actually enjoy your surroundings. The staff deserves special mention—they …

A
Ashlee Thomas

Simple Simon catered our wedding cake and desserts like cupcakes, pie, cheese cake, mini eclairs, and cream puffs. Everything was SO beautiful, and even more importantly, so delicious! They are a talented bakery, as every dessert was so perfect. I LOVED our wedding cake! We planned our wedding from California, and Dawn helped us the through the entire planning process- …

I
Isley Justinger

We had Simple Simon for our wedding at the Waters and everything was fantastic! We ordered a small cake just for the bride and the groom and it was perfect and decorated perfectly to match our nautical theme! We also ordered 5 different flavors of cupcakes for the guests and they absolutely loved them! Dawn was amazing setting it all …

A
Alyssa Brown

My husband and I recently got married this past June. Simple Simon Bakery made the process of planning our dessert menu easy. From the first meeting to the week leading up to the wedding, Dawn took the time to walk us through the process and answered all of our questions. We knew we wanted to add a personal touch by …

R
Rebecca Clark

We were visiting from Kentucky and it’s always a must to get donuts wherever we travel! These donuts were incredible! Flaky, soft & pillowy and cheap! The sticky bun was to die for! 10/10 recommend!!!

C
Clare Conteh-Morgan

We hired Simple Simon for our wedding cake and cupcakes. We could not be happier with our cake and cupcakes and the service! Our cake was beautiful and exactly what we wanted, and everything was delicious. We got four cupcake flavors: white, chocolate, carrot cake, and almond. The carrot cake was especially popular with our guests! We got exactly what …

K
Kaytlyn Walker

We chose Simple Simon Bakery for our wedding desserts, and it was one of the best decisions we made! Instead of a traditional cake, we went with their 3” mini pies and they were an absolute hit with our guests. Everyone loved them! We served a mix of pumpkin, caramel apple, classic apple, and cherry, and every flavor was delicious. …

E
Essi Love

I ordered my birthday cake from Simon's, and it was a great experience! The cake they made for me ended up looking exactly like my reference picture I showed them, it was so beautiful, and it was extremely moist and tasty. They said their heart-shaped cakes started at $60, but when I showed them all of the extra decor I …

K
Kevin & Lindsie Vander Heiden

We used Simple Simon for our wedding dessert needs. Instead of doing traditional cake, we decided to switch things up with wedding cheesecake (and some custom cookies/cake pops from our sister). Their cheesecake is some of the absolute best cheesecake we have ever had. Our guests devoured it. We had an initial consultation with Dawn who was super helpful. She …

People Also Ask

Where is Simple Simon Bakery located?
Simple Simon Bakery is located at 218 E Wisconsin Ave, Appleton, WI 54911, United States, Appleton, WI, United States. You can get directions here.
What is Simple Simon Bakery rated?
Simple Simon Bakery has a rating of 4.60 out of 5 stars based on 607 customer reviews.
What are Simple Simon Bakery's hours?
Simple Simon Bakery's hours vary by day. Please check the Business Hours section above for the full weekly schedule.
How do I contact Simple Simon Bakery?
You can reach Simple Simon Bakery by phone at +1 920-733-4351.
What type of business is Simple Simon Bakery?
Simple Simon Bakery is a restaurants business located in Appleton, WI. <!-- VOILA_REWRITTEN --> Discover Simple Simon Bakery, a standout Restaurants in Appleton, WI, known for fresh flavors, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. With a 4.60-star rating from 607 reviews, …