About Schultzy's Restaurant
Schultzy’s Restaurant is a welcoming seafood restaurant in Bayville, NY, offering a relaxed setting for enjoying satisfying meals and a range of dining options. Whether you are stopping in for lunch, dinner, brunch, dessert, or a casual solo meal, the restaurant provides a comfortable place to sit back and enjoy attentive table service. Guests can choose from dine-in, outdoor seating, takeaway, or delivery, making it convenient to enjoy Schultzy’s Restaurant in the way that best suits their plans. Catering is also available for occasions that call for food prepared and served beyond the restaurant. The menu features seafood alongside comfort food, healthy options, and small plates, with choices complemented by beer, cocktails, spirits, coffee, and other alcoholic beverages. Schultzy’s is known for its great beer selection, great cocktails, fast service, and local specialty, creating an appealing option for both relaxed meals and social gatherings. A bar on site and restroom facilities add to the convenience, while the casual atmosphere makes the restaurant easy to enjoy for everyday dining, a laid-back brunch, or an evening meal. Accessibility is an important part of the guest experience, with a wheelchair-accessible car park, entrance, seating, and toilet. Customers can make reservations in advance, and payments are accepted by credit card, debit card, and NFC mobile payment. With a 4.70 out of 5 rating based on 255 reviews, Schultzy’s Restaurant has earned strong customer feedback in the Bayville community. Visit 265 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709, United States, or call +1 516-588-6240 to learn more or plan your next visit.
Business Hours
Customer Reviews
My husband and I finally had the opportunity to visit Schultzy"s Restaurant not once but twice this past weekend! The first time we arrived without a reservation and we asked if Jimmy was there and was informed he wasn't - we shared our long history of his many backyard raw bars for our family parties. The staff was happy to …
The food was incredible. Although the restaurant is small, the seafood dishes are distinctive and full of flavor. The lobster and shrimp soup were particularly delicious, and the lobster roll with homemade fries was outstanding. The restaurant manager was exceptionally welcoming, making for a very enjoyable conversation.
Fantastic small seafood restaurant. Great food! Lobster Mac was awesome. Shrimp cocktail were huge. Blue point oysters were great. And I had a giant slice of halibut with a lemon sauce that was spot on perfect. Looks like they do custom catering too. Everyone at my table was super happy. We will be returning regularly.
We made a reservation for eight people after my son‘s first communion. One of the grandparents had a wheelchair and we weren’t sure how to get it in there. But Jimmy to the rescue – helped lift the wheelchair with my husband. They were so accommodating. Food was excellent. Service was great. Will definitely be going back.
I had a great light dinner there with my favorite type of food. A warm fresh baked roll, Lobster roll, little neck clams and beer. Service was great. The place is right but charming.
The owner Jimmy is a very nice guy! The food is awesome from the freshest oysters to the lobster rolls, baked clams are unforgettable!! They also have a good selection of wines and spirits.
Just finished lunch here and it was amazing. Everything was super fresh and Vicky’s cheesecake is a must-have!
The food did not disappoint. The drinks were quite good and the servers were attentive. I would definitely order the swordfish again. Very tasty. Other dishes ordered from the table were Fish and chips, Oysters and Steamers. Everyone enjoyed their food. We also sampled the desserts which were from local vendors. All plates were cleaned. No leftovers.
Went there for 35th wedding anniversary because my wife loves lobster. Parking was a problem even though we got there early. Service was friendly and attentive. Mostly a bar with some tables and gets crowded. Food was excellent but somewhat pricey. We will definitely go there when we win the lottery.
3x is a charm! My husband and I are always seeking and traveling to various restaurants in search of excellence. Recently, we stumbled upon Schultzy’s in Bayville, NY. Well just Wow!!! This place is absolutely phenomenal. We have tried numerous dishes from the menu and the daily specials. Nothing has fallen short - food is incredible. We can’t say enough …
