About Pizza & Libations
Pizza & Libations is a welcoming pizza restaurant in Bargersville, Indiana, where great food, refreshing drinks, and a comfortable atmosphere come together for memorable dining. Located at 75 Baldwin St, this local favorite is known for its casual, cozy, and trendy setting—an inviting place to enjoy a relaxed dinner, meet friends for happy hour, watch sports, or settle in for a satisfying solo meal. With a strong 4.70 out of 5 rating from 1,102 customer reviews, Pizza & Libations has earned a reputation for quality, friendly service, and an experience that keeps guests coming back. The menu offers something for every appetite, from comforting pizza and hearty dinner selections to shareable small plates and indulgent desserts. Guests can pair their meal with a carefully chosen beer selection, cocktails, wine, coffee, or other alcoholic and non-alcoholic options. Happy-hour food and drinks make it easy to unwind after work, while the on-site bar, fireplace, and table service add to the restaurant’s inviting character. Whether you are planning a casual night out, a special dinner, a catered gathering, or a quick meal on the go, Pizza & Libations provides flexible options including dine-in, takeaway, delivery, and outdoor seating. Fast service helps keep visits convenient without sacrificing the enjoyment of a thoughtfully prepared meal. Planning your visit is simple, with reservations accepted and payment available by credit card, debit card, and NFC mobile payments. The restaurant also offers free Wi-Fi, restrooms, and a fully accessible experience with a wheelchair-accessible car park, entrance, seating, and toilet. From a relaxed dinner and after-hours drinks to catering, dessert, and a comfortable table-service experience, Pizza & Libations brings together the food, hospitality, and convenience customers value most. To make a reservation, ask about catering, or place an order, call +1 317-771-3165.
Business Hours
Customer Reviews
Awesome food and service!! Salmon was cooked perfectly. Pork chop also cooked perfect. Very enjoyable experience!! Callia abd Amanda were great!!
Loved the difference twist on flavors and the best Spinach artichoke dip we’ve ever had. Our waitress Megan was a delight and very helpful on our choices. Will definitely enjoy going back!
A Slice of Heaven with a Side of Hospitality! Our first visit to Pizza & Libations was nothing short of spectacular. From the moment we walked through the doors, we were greeted with genuine warmth and promptly seated—setting the tone for an evening that only got better. 🍷 Service that Shines: Our server was a gem—friendly, knowledgeable, and clearly passionate …
Pizza and Libations exceeded my expectations! We ate here for the first time last night and WOW the food was amazing. Tyler our waiter was fantastic. The Brie bruschetta was so delicious. Meatballs were delicious. I have to have Italian sausage and spice in meatballs and these had both. The Godfather pizza was amazing! They also offer Happy Hour specials …
The service was incredible, the food was amazing and the overall restaurant as a whole is phenomenal...from bartender Gordon, to my waitress Jennea, and to the waitress who recommended a great drink, Ms. Lexie...I appreciate the hospitality and I'll definitely be back...
We travel to Indiana 3-4 times a year and P & L is a must stop on every trip! And, sometimes multiple times per trip. I am gluten free and they have the best GF pizza I have had. Hubs orders the Godfather pizza and says it’s yummy. The Aperol Spritz is great too. This trip we sat at the …
Stopped off for a rare Sunday happy hour. Food was solid and drinks were fantastic. Had the Italian mule and a Spritz. Both were fantastic. Will be back for happy hour drinks with friends again! Also had a 2 yo with us and the server knew exactly how to handle it. Plastic cup of water with a lid and placed …
We had a fantastic time. The breadsticks were delicious, and you can really taste the quality in their scratch-made pizzas. Plus they have Taxman Brewery beers! Our server was wonderful and made us feel right at home. We’ll definitely be back soon! 🍕🍻
Pizza is one of the best I have had! Drinks are great! Only negative things I could say is it may get a little loud at times and parking out front is limited so it’s almost always best to park across the tracks and walk over. All in all P&L will always be in rotation for our family!
This place was a STANDOUT at a recent Indy Track Event (Rev 2026) amongst a sea of other eateries. Soooo I went here to the brick and mortar in Bargersville. The pizza isn’t good- it’s GREAT. The staff are very sweet and on top of their craft. Kayli was a really great server and Athena was a great bartender- their …
