About Lorelei Bittner's Bakery
Since 1946, Lorelei Bittner's Bakery has been a cherished part of Lake Geneva, offering the kind of warmth, quality, and everyday comfort that only a trusted bakery and cake shop can provide. This easygoing counter-serve spot has long delighted customers with fresh baked goods that make mornings brighter, celebrations sweeter, and quick stops more satisfying. From cakes made for special moments to cookies and danishes perfect for an afternoon treat, every visit brings the promise of something freshly prepared and worth coming back for. Whether you are starting the day with breakfast, stopping in for coffee, or picking up a treat to share, the bakery brings together tradition, convenience, and a welcoming feel that keeps generations of customers returning. What makes Lorelei Bittner's Bakery especially appealing is the way it fits smoothly into busy everyday life while still feeling personal and memorable. Customers can enjoy in-store shopping, takeaway, kerbside pickup, delivery, in-store pick-up, and on-site services, making it easy to get exactly what they need in the way that works best for them. The bakery is also designed with accessibility in mind, featuring a wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance to help ensure a comfortable visit for more guests. With quick-visit planning in mind and flexible payment options including cheques, credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, the experience is built around ease and convenience. Backed by a strong 4.60-star rating from 304 reviews, Lorelei Bittner's Bakery stands out as a dependable local favorite where quality baked goods, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere come together beautifully. Located at 495 Interchange N in Lake Geneva, WI, Lorelei Bittner's Bakery is more than just a place to buy baked goods—it is a destination for comfort, celebration, and everyday enjoyment. For anyone looking for a bakery and cake shop that combines classic charm with practical convenience, it offers the kind of reliable experience that makes life a little sweeter. Call +1 262-248-2330 to learn more or plan your visit.
Business Hours
Customer Reviews
Amazing bakery items, pastries, cookies, etc.. My office is near the bakery so I stop by frequently to grab a handful of goodies to take to my clients. The cinnamon rolls are always a hit! Highly recommend!
Stopped on by since it was super close by a gas station. The worker was super nice and gave me some of her suggestions. Went with an apple Danish and a blueberry Danish. Both were super yummy and had great texture even though I came in within their last hour of being open. Would recommend checking it out!
They did an amazing job on 2 cakes I needed. One for my daughter graduation and one for my mom and dads 50 th wedding anniversary! I wanted cupcake cakes as a 23 and a 50! They did an amazing job! They were beautifully decorated and everything I wanted it to be! And tasted wonderful!!! Definitely will be ordering from …
Just discovered Lorelei Bittner's Bakery. It's wonderful. Smells so gummy. The selection is massive with many confections delicacies. Everything is fresh and homemade. Bittner's sells out many items fast so ordering ahead is recommended. Highly recommend.
We didn’t realize there was a bakery in the strip when we stopped in. We were actually there for the gas station next door. I’m glad we decided to check it out! We got a cream puff. Really good! My husband and I shared it and we were both happy. I got a Pineapple Upside Down Cake that was so …
In town for a concert. Decided to check out the local bakery. Service was fantastic. Woman behind the counter talked me through my decision making process. She was kind, patient and talkative. 5 stars Atmosphere: kind of a strip mall mext to a gas station. Clean inside and out. No seating inside. Beautiful, well displayed goods. Easy to find and …
I ordered 1 6” cake & 30 red velvet cupcakes for my daughters “you’re two sweet” birthday party, & not only did they respond to my inquiry within hours on a Monday (on their advertised day off!) & was able to get my order prepared by that Saturday. They were exactly what we wanted & more! The service was cordial …
They have med a few cakes for me in the past few years the women there is extremely nice an always does an overly amazing job the cakes turn out great an they are loved by the people they are for
We used Lorelei's bakery to make a red velvet cake for my Mom's 60th birthday. When I picked up the cake I wasn't thrilled about the design, it didn't give the wow factor I was hoping for based on the price I paid. I called the bakery back and asked them if they could jazz it up. They were extremely …
This review is long overdue. Amy and her team have been the key to creating our core memories over the years as we all gather around the cake to celebrate our special occasions. Any ideas I throw out there she is willing to accommodate and goes above and beyond my expectations. Thank you Bittner's for all your hard work and …
