About Library Café
Library Café is a top-rated American restaurant in NY 11735, known for serving satisfying meals in a warm, welcoming setting. With a 4.40-star reputation, this neighborhood favorite brings together classic American flavors, quality ingredients, and a relaxed dining experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back. Whether you’re stopping in for a casual lunch, a comfortable dinner, or a dependable place to enjoy timeless comfort food, Library Café delivers the kind of experience people look for in a trusted American restaurant. To experience one of the best American restaurants in NY 11735, visit Library Café and enjoy flavorful dishes, friendly service, and a memorable dining experience close to home.
Business Hours
Customer Reviews
We come here all the time. And we have a favorite bartender. His name is John. They have great book themed cocktails, named after Dr. Seuss, hemmingway, and more. The mocktails are also fabulous 👌🏼 Good vibes all around. Can't wait to come back soon! Thanks bartender John
We hosted a bridal shower yesterday at the Library Cafe in Farmingdale for my daughter. Everything went smoothly from start to finish. The staff were friendly and professional and the food was great. The restaurant which has its own unique fun vibe allows you to add your own decor etc to make the experience more personal. Everyone had a great …
This was a refreshing experience after a "wellness walk" thru Geiger Park and gardens. The food selections would suit all pallets. Excellent cobb salad, one of the best I've ever had and I've had pleny. Fresh greens, avocado, egg, tomato, bacon and grilled chicken and no blue cheese or black olives. My friends equally enjoyed their Buddha bowls and fried …
One of my absolute favorite bar/restaurants in the town of Farmingdale. The food is superb and the drinks?! Don't even get me started on the drinks! Easily, some of the best drinks I have ever had. There isn't the widest selection of seating but if you can get in you're in for a treat!
Great bar and restaurant with a really welcoming atmosphere. The spinach artichoke dip is honestly some of the best I’ve ever had rich, flavorful, and perfectly balanced the chips are fresh and is great with the pita as well. The tuna poke tacos were also amazing, super fresh with great texture and flavor. The bar itself has plenty of space, …
Atmosphere and good food meet in a historical location. Variety of food and drinks, great service all around, my dish came in quickly and tasted great. Had an apple tart which was nothing short of wonderful. Visit this place at least once - you will not regret it
I was in town for business from San Antonio and checked this place out after walking the street deciding where to dine for lunch. I immediately felt comfortable and was impressed with ambience and decor of the restaurant. The bar is impressive with the bottles placed so high a ladder is necessary to reach their height. My server was very …
I have had lunch at Library Cafe several times and the food is fantastic. I really enjoy the fish and chips with their coleslaw, tartar sauce and malt vinegar. Their All American burger is very good with a beer at the bar.
Phenomenal place to have a lunch date or meet a friend. Their salads are truly my favorite. Including the taco one. They also have this apple tart dessert. Dream come true for the taste buds. Also, have to note that the servers are ALWAYS so friendly and sweet. Never a bad experience here. Come by and have a good time.
I was actually on my way to a different coffee shop, but anyone with an advanced degree knows there’s simply no legal way to walk past a place called “Library” without investigating. Academic instincts took over. Very glad they did. The food was excellent, the cocktails surprisingly creative, and the atmosphere felt effortlessly polished. The crowd had that unmistakable old-money …