About Lake Geneva Pie Co
Lake Geneva Pie Co is a trusted local restaurant in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, known for offering quality service and a welcoming experience that keeps customers coming back. Conveniently located at 150 E Geneva Square, this neighborhood favorite brings together the comfort of a friendly local business and the appeal of a destination worth visiting. Whether you’re stopping in for a casual meal, looking for a place that feels inviting and dependable, or simply want to enjoy great food in a relaxed setting, Lake Geneva Pie Co offers the kind of experience that makes dining out feel easy and worthwhile. What sets Lake Geneva Pie Co apart is its strong reputation and the confidence it has built with the community. With a customer rating of 4.40 out of 5 based on 449 reviews, the restaurant reflects a consistent commitment to quality and satisfaction. That kind of feedback speaks to more than just good food—it points to attentive service, a welcoming atmosphere, and a dependable dining experience that guests can trust. As a local business, Lake Geneva Pie Co takes pride in serving customers with care, making it a valuable part of the Lake Geneva dining scene and a place where great service and community spirit come together. For anyone seeking a reliable restaurant in Lake Geneva, Lake Geneva Pie Co offers the convenience of a centrally located spot, the reassurance of strong customer reviews, and the comfort of a business that values quality. To learn more about what they offer or to plan your visit, you can reach them at +1 262-248-5100.
Business Hours
Customer Reviews
This one is a gem. I am at least once a month in lake geneva for work and when I am here I always come here. They have a good variety of sweets, but the cherry pie is top notch. If you have a sweet tooth as I do, I would definitely recommend to try this place
Nice selection of fresh pies I'm really enjoying and liking all the pies I've bought so far, one blueberry, one apple one cherry and one Cherry crunch, very good pies, I'll be back.
Delicious. We had raspberry pie, raspberry orange muffin, chipotle cheese quiche and oatmeal cookie. The quiche and baked items were nice and moist.
Visited today for the first time. Had a slice of cherry pie and strawberry rhubarb crunch. DELISH! Both of them! Employees were very friendly and very helpful with all our questions. Got a Lake Berry to bring home and a frozen take and bake peach to bring home! Pie crust is amazing! Will def be back every time we visit …
Wonderful friendly staff, amazing assortment of pies to choose from, soups and quiches also available, delicious as they look! A must stop if you are in the area! Best chocolate cream pie I ever had!
Oh my goodness; the Cherry Crumb pie! Absolutely delicious! I tried my friends' apple crumble pie & that also was incredible. We tried the peanut butter cookies & they were so soft. Incredible place. It is SO cute inside. It has tiny tick tac toe game at the tables. Adorable. The service was incredible! Sweetest staff ever. Good coffee too!
Their pie is the best. Banana cream and berry are delish. The lady working the counter makes you feel warm & fuzzy. Always stop on our way thru town
This is fabulous! Why aren't there any pie restaurants in Florida? I had chicken and broccoli pie, quiche, and apple pie. All great.
We needed a Key Lime pie last minute and Lake Geneva Pie Company completely saved the day. They were incredibly accommodating with our short-notice request and were so kind and helpful each time we called to coordinate. When we went to get it, the pickup process was quick and completely hassle-free. Best of all, the pie itself was awesome! Hands …
Wonderful pies, fruit, cream, pot pies, cookie, soups, and quiche’s! Can really settle a sweet tooth or savory tooth in 1 visit! Cute little quaint shop too! Staff and owner were all lovely and helpful!! We will be back! Thank goodness my sister lives near here in Wisconsin, we are from St. Louis!
