About Johnson's BBQ Shack
Johnson’s BBQ Shack in Bargersville, Indiana, brings together satisfying barbecue, welcoming hospitality, and excellent value in a casual, cozy setting. With menu prices typically ranging from $10–20, it is an inviting choice for a quick bite, a relaxed lunch, a hearty dinner, or an easy meal with friends and family. Guests can enjoy comfort food, small plates, desserts, and local specialties, with counter service and table service available to suit different dining preferences. Whether you are stopping in for a solo meal or gathering with a group, Johnson’s BBQ Shack makes it easy to enjoy flavorful food without stretching your budget. The restaurant offers dine-in, takeaway, delivery, outdoor seating, and on-site services, giving customers flexibility for every occasion. A bar on site serves beer, cocktails, spirits, and wine, while the comfortable atmosphere is complemented by a fireplace, live music, and sports—making it a great place to unwind, catch a game, or share a meal. Johnson’s BBQ Shack is also known for lunch, dinner, catering, and dependable service, with reservations accepted for guests who want to plan ahead. Free Wi-Fi, gender-neutral toilets, and a restroom add to the convenience, while wheelchair-accessible parking, an accessible entrance, accessible seating, and an accessible toilet help ensure a more comfortable visit for everyone. Rated 4.40 out of 5 based on 858 customer reviews, Johnson’s BBQ Shack has earned strong feedback from diners seeking quality food, fast service, and a friendly experience. Payment is simple and convenient, with credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments accepted. Visit the restaurant at 82 S Baldwin St, Bargersville, IN 46106, or call +1 317-458-4660 to learn more, arrange catering, or plan your next meal.
Customer Reviews
Definitely a win. We had pulled pork, brisket, potato salad, baked beans, and macaroni and cheese, all were delicious. They serve beer as well, and handcrafted sodas. Manager Chris came to check on us and the service was phenomenal. Will be back!
Phenomenal food. Great service. Friendly people. Clean room. Classic smokehouse. We stopped in for lunch and ordered a couple sampler platters. We tried pulled pork, brisket, pork chop, and jalapeno sausage. Also the potato salad, mac n cheese, and corn casserole. Sampled the sugar cream pie as well. The soda machine is special too. They peddle locally made pop, and …
Been hearing about this place for months and we finally came down. So mad I waited this long. Wonderful pulled pork and the sides were all very good. Next time I'll try the ribs which looked amazing. Sauces are so good we bought some bottles to take home. This is worth the drive down from anywhere in Indy.
This is one of the best bbq places I’ve ever had me and my wife love this place!
Wow! A friend recommended and took us to Johnson’s... Delicious BBQ! Super quick counter service bbq. A bit of a drive but totally worth it. Looks like they have a nice patio area for the spring and summer time highly recommended!
I am telling you when I am a barbecue fan Johnson's BBQ shack just touched my soul!!! That brisket sandwich though🥹 I'm not understanding why it's so slow in there. They need to change location because this food right here deserves every dollar they're asking plus gratuity. Very delicious very great service and well clean atmosphere! Plus I offered to …
I was greeted by a friendly fella as soon as I walked in. Had a nice quick chat and ordered. I got the brisket combo without the bun and sweet corn casserole🤤(better than your grama's just don't tell her😉). I used the sweet sauce on the brisket and mmm it was good. Combo comes with a drink. They are local …
The food: The ½ pound of meat I got was PHENOMENAL. The sauce was PHENOMENAL. The corn pudding was PHENOMENAL. The service: the lady who served me was incredibly friendly and my food came out in about 2 minutes. The atmosphere: I like joints like this. Cinder block walls, sauce purchasing display, big family style tables available. Sports playing but …
Johnson's BBQ Shack lived up to our expectations. It has been quite some time since we last visited the Bargersville location, and I swear the food tastes even better now. My son loved his Pulled Chicken Sandwich with the sweet BBQ sauce so much so he almost forgot he had ordered Mac & Cheese as his side dish. He is …
Excellent local BBQ place with friendly and helpful servers. I dined in from out of town and they were eager to help me understand the menu and pick options to try different types of meats. Clean, organized, nice soda options (HFC free!) and fun sides (try the sweet corn casserole.) Would recommend to any BBQ fan in the area.
