About Cake Lady
Cake Lady is a welcoming bakery and cake shop in Warsaw, Indiana, where beautifully made treats and convenient service come together to create a memorable experience for every customer. Located at 2475 E Pierceton Rd, Warsaw, IN 46580, this local favorite is known for offering the kind of fresh, comforting baked goods that make everyday moments feel special and celebrations feel complete. Whether you are looking for a custom cake for an important occasion, a sweet treat to enjoy on the spot, or something delicious to take home and share, Cake Lady provides a dependable and inviting place to find quality desserts made with care. What makes Cake Lady especially appealing is the way it fits into busy lives without sacrificing warmth or quality. Customers can choose from takeaway, delivery, or dine-in service, making it easy to enjoy their favorites in whatever way works best. The shop is designed for a quick visit, which is ideal for anyone who needs something wonderful without a long wait. Accessibility is also thoughtfully addressed, with a wheelchair-accessible car park that helps make visits more convenient for a wider range of guests. Payment is simple and flexible too, with cheques, credit cards, and debit cards accepted for added ease at checkout. With an excellent 4.80 out of 5 rating based on 37 reviews, Cake Lady has clearly earned the trust and appreciation of its customers. That strong reputation reflects more than just good baking—it speaks to consistent service, attention to detail, and a commitment to making every order feel worthwhile. For those in Warsaw and the surrounding area, Cake Lady offers more than a bakery stop; it offers peace of mind, dependable quality, and the pleasure of knowing that a special dessert is just a call away at +1 574-253-2705.
Customer Reviews
My mom put the tortoise in my stocking for Christmas and it was the best chocolate candy I've ever had! I couldn't stop eating it. Seriously, the texture was perfect, the flavor was sweet and salty, it was the perfect dessert! I cant wait to order more and try some new ones!
I attended a WACC banquet. I don't enjoy cake, but I love the Cake Lady's cake. I was hesitant to eat my cupcake, but took one bite and knew it was from the cake lady. It was delicious
We ordered the strawberries and cream cake for my Mother-in-Laws 88th birthday and it was fabulous!! This is the third time we ordered a cake from here. Each one was supremely delicious and always decorated so beautifully. We will definitely order from The Cake Lady again. My mouth is watering just thinking about it! Thank you so much!!
The best cake and other desserts I have ever had!
Being able to get goodies on the go and pick just an item or two is great! Nothing here will disappoint!
She is always willing to go above and beyond for my cakes and cupcakes. Truly amazing! Will never go to a different bakery
We ordered gender reveal cake pops, and they were absolutely perfect! Not only were they delicious, but the attention to detail was incredible, you truly couldn’t tell which one was the blue cake pop. It made the reveal so much more special and fun! She was also kind enough to take on our order with short notice, and still went …
The Cake Lady baked our bridal party cake & guest cupcakes for our wedding! The trial (taste test) was easy and fun, and Sarah made our vision come to life both in terms of flavor and of the look of it all. So yummy and will definitely be back for more in the future. Thank you so much!!!
It was the best cheesecake I've ever tasted! My friends agreed! My dad had me pick up a blueberry cheesecake for my mom and she liked it! Feb. 14, 2020 another delicious strawberry topped cheesecake and the cupcakes this year!
The Cake Lady went above and beyond for our celebration today! The cake she made for Redwood Warsaw’s 6th birthday was not only beautiful but absolutely delicious. The design was perfect—clean, professional, and exactly what we envisioned with our logo front and center. From the first bite, you can tell the quality and care that goes into her work. Moist, …
