About Bite Me Bakery
Bite Me Bakery is a welcoming bakery and cake shop in Wheeling, West Virginia, where small-town warmth meets big, memorable flavor. Proudly serving the local community from 2137 Market St, this neighborhood favorite is the kind of place customers return to for more than just a quick bite—it is a destination for fresh breakfast favorites, comforting coffee, and the kind of baked goods that make mornings feel brighter and celebrations feel more special. Whether you are stopping in for a relaxed breakfast, picking up something sweet, or choosing the perfect treat for an occasion, Bite Me Bakery brings the charm and quality that make a bakery truly stand out. With on-site service available, customers can enjoy the friendly, convenient experience of visiting in person and taking in everything the shop has to offer. The bakery’s reputation is backed by a strong 4.70 out of 5 rating from 63 reviews, reflecting the consistent satisfaction of guests who appreciate both the quality of the food and the inviting atmosphere. Accepted payment options include debit cards, credit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making each visit easy and hassle-free. For those looking for a reliable bakery and cake shop that combines excellent service, great coffee, and a trusted local feel, Bite Me Bakery offers a delicious reason to stop by again and again.
Customer Reviews
I really wish they had mail order. The blondies with banana cream icing were out of this world! They’re worth the 5 hour drive (one way). Great service and a really nice atmosphere as well. Will definitely be back.
We recently purchased custom sugar cookies for a retirement party. The cookies were delicious and everyone commented on how great they were. The tasted great and were beautiful! I would absolutely recommend and will be purchasing more in the future.
I purchased a chocolate peanut butter cake they had on display in the bakery. It was perfect for my dad's birthday and everyone in my family enjoyed it so much! Moist, rich, yummy, and so beautiful! So glad Wheeling has a good place to get a cake (that is not from a supermarket) and it's so convenient in Centre Market! …
Ordered my moms 50th birthday cake, saying I was absolutely blown away by the cake I received was an understatement. To top it off it also tasted even better than it looked. She really went above and beyond, even took the time to send me a finished photo before I came and picked it up. Would 10000% recommend coming here …
We were in town for our 19 year wedding anniversary with our twins and research the cutest bakery in town and my goodness we found it! We even had a chance to meet the owner and she was absolutely delightful and made sure we had the perfect cup of coffee to start our adventure that day! We loved picking out …
I’ve heard nothing but good things about this bakery for over a year now and finally took the time to stop in and try some sweets a few weeks ago. I was instantly obsessed. The cookies, blondies, macarons… they’re all phenomenal! We ordered some “bite size” sugar cookies for my niece’s bridal shower yesterday and they were the most beautiful …
I ordered a birthday cake for my wife and not only was it able to be made exactly as asked, it was one of the best cake’s we have had. Definitely worth the price! The owner was very nice and easy to work with. Would definitely recommend and will be going back!
My bf & I stopped into Bite Me Bakery yesterday about an hour before they closed. While the person working did warn us that their selection was pretty picked over by that point, we still found some delicious items! We tried a couple of chocolate chip cookies & a couple lemon cranberry shortbread cookies - both were great! The inside …
I am obsessed with this little bakery. Everything is homemade and the owner is a peach. They obviously really care about the business and the quality. They offer a variety of different flavors every day so if you have a sweet tooth like me you always have a chance to try something a little different. The doughnuts are dense but …
Delicious sweet and savory pastry selection, the almond cookie was fantastic!! We got the bagel filled bites, a blue berry danish, a biscotti and a cinnamon. All of them were amazing and great prices too!
